Claim Information

Claims Reporting Information
If you are reporting a claim during regular business hours, please call us at: 513-732-1461 (Batavia) or 937-783-2424 or 800-223-9094 (Blanchester).  After business hours or on weekends, you may report the claim directly to the company at one of the numbers listed below:
American Modern Home	800-375-2075	Report your claim online
Auto Owners	888-252-4626 (After hours)	Report your claim online
Buckeye State Mutual	800-672-3558 (M-F 8am - 6pm)   800-672-3558, ext. 500 (After hours)
Celina / Miami Mutual	800-231-2318
Foremost	800-527-3907	Report your claim online
Grange	800-445-3030
Hastings Mutual	800-442-8277
Infinity	800-334-1661
Lightning Rod / Western Reserve	800-362-0426
Miami Mutual	800-231-2318
Ohio Fair Plan	800-282-1772	Procedures/Property Claim Form
Progressive	800-274-4499	Online reporting
State Auto	800-766-1853	Report your claim online
Victoria	800-926-3168
West Bend	877-922-5246